Press "Enter" to skip to content

A Calmer Cromwell Day at Smith Where Solidarity Took Center Stage

This year’s theme, “Building Community Through Solidarity,” drew students into conversations about history, harm and healing

On Nov. 10, students, staff and faculty gathered across Smith College campus for its annual Cromwell Day celebration, unfolding this year without the student protests sparked by last year’s speaker selection.

Cromwell Day honors the legacies of Smith’s first African American graduate, Otelia Cromwell, class of 1900, and her niece, Adelaide Cromwell ‘40, Smith’s first African American professor. Each year, the college hosts a day-long agenda of workshops, performances, exhibits and readings, where the Smith community is invited to reflect on racism, inclusivity and diversity on campus.

At the 2025 Cromwell Day, however, student organizers staged a walkout during the keynote address, delivered by Farah Pandith ’90, a foreign policy strategist and former diplomat specializing in countering violent extremism. She most recently served as the first special representative to Muslim communities.

But many argued that Pandith’s professional background conflicted with the equity and justice values the day is meant to promote. Last year, student organizers criticized Pandith’s roles in several U.S. government organizations, including the Department of Homeland Security, the National Security Council, as well as the Anti-Defamation League.

In a social media statement Smith’s Student Power Coalition wrote that Pandith “has built her career on combating extremist ideology by promoting American imperialism and exceptionalism abroad.”

In response to the backlash, the college hosted Q&As and listening sessions to hear students’ concerns. Students subsequently organized a town hall, generating a list of suggestions on how to better involve the entire Smith community in the planning of Cromwell Day.

There was no keynote walkout this year. In alignment with this year’s theme, “Building Community Through Solidarity,” Alaina E. Roberts, a scholar of Black and Native American history, illuminated the largely untold history of Black Americans’ enslavement within Native American communities. 

Roberts is herself a descendant of Black Chickasaws. Today, she is fighting for this history to be acknowledged, and for the enslaved Black Chickasaws and their descendants to be granted Chickasaw citizenship.

After publishing her first book, “I’ve Been Here All the While,” Roberts began receiving emails from Chickasaw citizens who were unfamiliar with the realities her work explores. “The emails that I got from Chickasaws grew into relationships. And those relationships convinced me that my path needs to be education, not just in books, but also through outreach to Chickasaw citizens,” said Roberts.

Now, through events and appearances at tribal events, Roberts says she hopes to build a network of support and dismantle the culture of fear and repression surrounding conversations about enslavement in Chickasaw communities.

“True solidarity is advocating for the most marginalized among us. Even when it’s uncomfortable, even when it’s risky and even when it makes us question the narratives that we hold dear,” said Roberts.

Many students praised Roberts’ talk, agreeing that her research aligned more with the theme and Cromwell Day values as a whole. 

“To me, this year’s speaker held more relevance to the actual meaning and importance of Cromwell Day and the importance of uplifting voices of color, but in a way where we acknowledge history,” said Valerie Fabian-Siri ‘29.

Audrey Jiggetts ‘27 emphasized the importance of Roberts’ talk. “I think it shows how much history involving African Americans, Native Americans and the slave trade in general is still not uncovered,” said Jiggetts. 

This year’s keynote and workshops asked what solidarity requires when communities that have faced oppression have also hurt other peoples, as Jiggetts put it. 

“I think that was really powerful what she said about people in the [Chickasaw] community who are willing to acknowledge that,” said Jiggetts. “I think that’s a hard thing to stomach, so I think that it’s great that some people are receptive.”

Following the address were afternoon and evening programming, one of which was a workshop titled “Building Solidarity in Times of Crisis,” hosted by the Smith African and Caribbean Student Association (SACSA) and the Pan-African Student Association (PASA).

The event opened with two presentations delivered by Anna K. Mwaba, assistant professor of Government, and Maria Andam, Gwendolyn Carter lecturer in African Studies. They focused on the African continent, aiming to challenge its stereotypes, give a contextualized look at the activism happening there and define meaningful solidarity across geographical and ideological boundaries.

Then, in facilitated exercises led by SACSA and PASA members, participants were encouraged to reflect on what solidarity looks like. In groups, students shared their visions of solidarity in practice, like knowing one’s neighbors, implementing localized support networks and uplifting reciprocity and mutual aid.

One SACSA member, Winetta Adams ‘28, reflected on the general mood. “I would say this [Cromwell Day] felt more community-centered,” she said. “I feel like even some of the other workshops on campus focus more on taking some of the criticism from previous Cromwell Days and building on that.”

Many at the event echoed the importance of having conversations about intersectionality and solidarity now, especially considering rising political tensions worldwide. “It sheds a light on how capable we are as humans when you have events like this. It’s just a good reminder that we’re more than just our problems,” said Mwaba.

Programming throughout the day also included a screening of “The Life and Legacy of Otelia Cromwell,” a workshop honoring the contributions of Smith’s first Native American graduate, Angel DeCora, a workshop on indigenous notions of plant-human kinship, and a performance of “M’le bato: Are You My People?,” an original play by The Performance Project.

ej seibert ‘08, Vice President for Equity and Inclusion, and student Cromwell Day emcees Jode Redding ‘30, Salma Baksh ‘28, Jasmine Bhakta ‘27 and Irene Ham ‘28 opened the keynote address by introducing changes made to planning in response to students’ demands last year. 

According to Baksh, the Cromwell Day committee communicates more consistently with the campus’s unity organizations, and emcee duties, which are now shared between students and administrators, are also paid positions for students. They also coordinated with events management and communications in August to promote Cromwell Day earlier in the semester, Baksh said.

seibert encouraged attendees to share further feedback with the Office of Equity and Inclusion.

For many, this year’s Cromwell Day was not only a reminder of the solidarities yet to be built, but the solidarity that already exists on campus. Students and faculty echoed that, despite anticipating political challenges both domestically and abroad, the day evoked feelings of hope, optimism and campus connection. 

“Because the world is going through such difficult times, and sometimes it feels like we’re the only one suffering, a little bit,” said Mwaba. “[Solidarity reminds us that] there’s other people who share our struggles, that we can learn from others just beyond the little space that we occupy. I think it’s very important.”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *