NORTHAMPTON – Since returning to office in Jan. 2025, President Donald Trump has quickly signed a series of executive orders. From imposing new tariffs to renaming the Gulf of Mexico the “Gulf of America” to introducing policies that endanger immigrant communities, Trump has used his presidential power to advance his political agenda. One of his most controversial executive orders has targeted transgender athletes, particularly transgender women.
Although the administration has framed these policies as a way to “protect women’s sports,” they unfairly marginalize and discriminate against the LGBTQ+ community, ultimately promoting transphobia across America. “There’s a lot of discourse around trans athletes and where they can compete in. I would welcome a trans athlete on my team or against my team anytime. I don’t think it’s a problem in the world. It’s just another way to kind of attack trans people,” said Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA) Player Gabby Williams in an interview with Jackie Powell for Them. Williams later went on to lead the Golden State Valkyries to their first WNBA Championship as the Most Valuable Player in the 2026 Finals series, bringing light to the atrocity of the trans athletes in sports conversation.
The debate over transgender athletes has become a major political conversation, raising questions about fairness in sports, gender identity, and equal access to competition. However, the consequence for transgender athletes goes beyond not being able to play on a team that matches their gender identity. As political conversations and restrictions grow, athletes have increasingly found themselves at the center of a national argument that places their identities, safety, and passions under a magnifying glass.
On Feb. 5, 2025, Trump signed an executive order titled “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports.” The order seeks to prohibit transgender women from participating in women’s sports and threatens investigations into schools and institutions that allow them to compete. This presents transgender athlete participation as a possible violation of Title IX–a federal law that prohibits sex-based discrimination in educational programs that receive federal funding.
During the signing ceremony, Trump declared, “From now on women’s sports will only be for women,” adding, “with this executive order, the war on women’s sports is over.”
Although executive orders must follow existing laws and can be challenged in court, the announcement quickly influenced sports organizations across the country. The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and other athletic leagues began to remove transgender athlete participation from their policies.
However, the political debate did not begin with Trump’s second term. Discussions about transgender participation in competitive sports gained traction and national attention around 2020, particularly following the success of University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas, who won an NCAA championship in 2022.
Thomas’s victory became a major focal point in the debate, attracting both support and criticism. Riley Gaines, a swimmer who competed against Thomas in the NCAA championship, became one of the most vocal critics of transgender women’s participation in women’s sports. Gaines later worked with conservative political figures and organizations to argue that transgender women have an unfair athletic advantage over cisgender women.
The debate increasingly focused on claims that transgender women were taking awards, recognition, and opportunities from cisgender women. What started as a discussion about athletic eligibility grew into a wider political campaign targeting transgender people.
While political leaders and advocacy groups continue to debate who should be allowed to compete, transgender athletes have experienced the personal consequences of being thrust into the national spotlight.
In November 2024, NCAA volleyball player Blaire Fleming became the target of public scrutiny. Fleming’s teammate, Brooke Slusser, later joined a lawsuit initiated by Riley Gaines challenging the NCAA’s transgender inclusion policies. The lawsuit brought further attention to Fleming’s identity as a trans woman and her membership on the team.
Slusser claimed that Fleming’s volleyball spikes reached speeds of approximately 80 miles per hour, describing them as faster than those she had ever seen from other women. One particular spike hit an opposing player, Keira Herron, in the face.
Herron later addressed the incident, saying, “It was fine… I was fine, the ball didn’t hurt.” She added, “Everyone gets hit in volleyball. It comes with the game, man.”
Despite Herron’s comments, Fleming faced extensive online harassment. Her social media accounts received millions of comments calling her disgusting and wishing death threats upon her. The harassment and attention had a serious impact on Fleming’s mental health, as she began struggling with suicidal thoughts, leaving her questioning whether she could continue playing volleyball.
In an interview with The New York Times, Fleming described the experience as “the darkest time in my life,” recalling nights she spent crying.
Fleming’s experience highlights the major mental health consequences of turning transgender athletes into political pawns.
A similar controversy emerged at Ithaca College, where members of the varsity rowing team faced criticism after allowing a transgender athlete assigned male at birth to participate. The athlete reportedly received death threats and sustained verbal harassment before eventually quitting the team.
One of the most common arguments against transgender women’s participation in women’s sports is that being assigned male at birth gives athletes physical advantages that make competition unfair. However, athletic performance is influenced by more than just sex. An athlete’s sex alone cannot determine their competitive ability or guarantee athletic success.
Factors such as genetics, training, physical conditioning, coordination, and experience all contribute to athletic performance. While physical differences can matter in sports, they do not automatically guarantee whether an individual can reach athletic success or not.
The assumption that men are naturally better athletes than women also overlooks the skill, training, and achievements of women in competitive sports. Athletes such as Coco Gauff, Simone Biles, and Williams will always win against a randomly selected man.
Discussions about fairness should rely on more than assumptions about an athlete’s sex assigned at birth. Policies governing transgender participation should consider scientific research while recognizing that athletic performance and physical differences vary among people and across sports.
The number of transgender athletes competing in college sports also raises questions about the amount of attention devoted to the issue.
During congressional testimony on Dec. 17, 2024, NCAA President Charlie Baker was questioned about the number of transgender athletes participating across the league.
Baker identified approximately 510,000 NCAA athletes in total. When asked how many transgender athletes he knew were actively competing, he responded, “Less than 10.”
The conversation highlights the relatively small number of transgender athletes participating in college sports compared with the overall student-athlete population. Despite their limited representation, transgender athletes have become the focus of significant political attention, campaigns, and national controversy.
The small number of athletes involved does not make the issue or their rights any less important. Rather, it raises the question: Why has such a small group become the center of such a large political debate?
For transgender athletes, participating in sports means more than competing. It provides one with a community, the chance to be seen, and a sense of belonging. Excluding athletes because of their gender identity denies them opportunities that other cisgender athletes are given: the ability to participate, connect with their teammates, and play the sport they love.
The debate has also prompted criticism of the Republican Party’s broader priorities.
During a House debate over H.R. 28, a bill addressing transgender participation in women’s sports, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez criticized Republicans for using transgender athletes as political scapegoats. She questioned the party’s commitment to women’s safety, pointing to its opposition to other policies intended to protect women, including the “Violence Against Women Act” and overall reproductive rights.
“Now [they] want to pretend today that they care about women,” Ocasio-Cortez said. “Bigoted folks love this bill, assaulters love this bill, but also CEOs love this bill. Because Los Angeles is on fire right now and this is the number one priority this majority has.”
Her comments reflected a broader criticism of the attention given to transgender athletes while other urgent issues demand government action and resources. At the time, California was experiencing devastating wildfires that displaced families and destroyed communities. Meanwhile, the humanitarian crisis and war in Gaza continued to claim innocent civilian lives.
The argument is not that conversations about athletic fairness should be ignored. Rather, transgender athletes should not be used as political scapegoats or as justification for policies that disproportionately target an already marginalized population.
Athletic eligibility should be based on credible scientific research and should consider the safety, mental health, and dignity of all athletes–like these policies claim to be designed for. Instead of relying on broad restrictions and political arguments, athletic organizations should consider data-based approaches that recognize the differences between sports, levels of competition, and individual athletes.
Sports have long been a space for community, personal drive, and social belonging. Transgender athletes should have the opportunity to experience those same benefits without being reduced to political talking points.
The question facing athletic organizations and policymakers isn’t about who should and who shouldn’t be allowed to compete. It’s whether sports can remain spaces where individuals are evaluated as athletes rather than targeted for what’s between their legs.
Transgender athletes deserve the right to compete, to feel a sense of belonging, and, most importantly, to pursue their passions just like any other person can.






Be First to Comment