Press "Enter" to skip to content

We Need to Reassess the Project of Journalism

  The decision to place OpenAI CEO Sam Altman at the top of their New Establishment list (with Tesla and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk coming in at number three) and on their October cover brings the intentions of Vanity Fair into question. The list, described as identifying “people who have defined the moment,” is one of many media inventions that serve to provide a spotlight for individuals who are harming society without any meaningful examination of that harm. It is an example of the placid acceptance figures like Altman and Musk are being met with, and the insidious intent behind platforming them. When confronted directly about this issue, Vanity Fair’s Global Editorial Director Mark Guiducci’s response exemplified an approach to journalism that has contributed to this bleak cultural moment.

On Oct. 2, 2026, American playwright Jeremy O. Harris sat down with Guiducci for Vanity Fair’s interview show Fair Game, during which he criticized the decision to platform tech oligarchs like Altman and Musk. Harris has previously made headlines for confronting Altman at the March 2026 Vanity Fair Oscar party, calling him the “Goebbels of the Trump administration” in reference to the chief propagandist of the Nazi Party, Joseph Goebbels. Harris later clarified: “It was late and I had a few too many martinis, so I misspoke when I said, Goebbels. I should’ve said, Friedrich Flick.” 

Friedrich Flick, another Nazi, was an industrialist who was one of the wealthiest people in the world at the time of his death. Altman donated one million dollars to Trump’s inaugural fund in Dec. 2024, “President Trump will lead our country into the age of AI, and I am eager to support his efforts to ensure America stays ahead,” said Altman.

During his interview with Guiducci, Harris said: “I do think that, like, you and Anna [Wintour] and so many other people around the world have such immense power over these people’s self-perception, right? Their perception of themselves as people who are or are not a part of society.” Guiducci responded with, “I view my job, and the job of the magazine, to reflect society.” 

Harris said, “You guys are advertising people…they should be told they’re ugly and bad for society for the rest of their lives until they start doing more for society.” 

“I don’t think that’s the project of journalism,” Guiducci said.

This response is emblematic of the passivity and capitulation shown by so many journalists in America in response to rising fascism. Altman and Musk are not only techno-fascists in their own right but have shown support for an administration that should be defined by its cruelty toward marginalized people. Platforming them under the guise of reflecting society is weakness and only serves to further legitimize people who are actively causing harm. 

Even the title of Guiducci’s October 2026 editor’s letter, “Editor’s Letter: Welcome to the Artificial Age-For Better or Worse,” evokes surrender. This is not the language that should be used or the lens through which these individuals should be viewed. 

Journalists should present a challenge to corruption, not enable it. 

We must always question who the media chooses to platform and why. I believe that journalists and the publications they work for act with intention, and that they must be held accountable for perpetuating the infamy of those causing societal harm. Infamy and legitimacy can overlap with an alarming quickness. 

People once laughed at the prospect of Trump becoming president. He is now in his second term, and the damage that has been done cannot be overstated. It was a mistake that the virulent hatred he expressed toward marginalized people was dismissed so readily. It is a mistake that I am seeing being repeated again and again. Altman and Musk should be under an investigation as ruthless as they themselves operate, and that any permissive language in relation to them should be obliterated. 

It is the project of journalism to interrogate society and expose vital truths. That is not the approach that many major publications have taken during the Trump era. Instead, they have either platformed the laundering of harmful ideas or the proponents of these ideas themselves. We must question why these publications are inventing reasons to mention these people and the tone being used. The project of journalism should not be a reflection without wider contextualization and examination. We must ask more from the American media. 

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *